Metal vs Plastic Gutter Mesh: Which Should You Choose?

Metal vs Plastic Gutter Mesh: Which Should You Choose?

by | Jul 22, 2022 | General

If you’ve never bought gutter mesh before, trying to select the right mesh for your home can feel overwhelming.  

While it’s obvious that differences such as aperture (hole size), installation, manufacture and colour mean that not all gutter mesh is created equal, it can be difficult to know what this actually means for you and your home.  

However, if you’re in the market for gutter mesh, one of the most important differences to consider is the material your mesh is made from.

Mesh materials 

In Australia, most gutter mesh is made from plastic, aluminium or a form of steel. Your choice of mesh materials will depend on many factors, including your budget, mesh strength requirements, bushfire risk and more. So it’s important to consider your property’s location, environment and needs as you compare the different options that are available.  

UV  

Steel and aluminium are naturally resistant to UV breakdown, so if you’re planning on using steel or aluminium, UV isn’t a problem.

If you’re considering using a plastic gutter mesh, always check with the supplier or manufacturer to get details on its UV performance. UV treatments can extend the life of plastic gutter mesh, but different treatments will come with different length warranties.

Fire  

Heat-resistant aluminium and steel gutter mesh products are non-combustible, meaning they shouldn’t burn if your home is exposed to bushfire or ember attack. Similarly, many plastic gutter meshes are designed to be non-combustible, meaning they don’t burn when exposed to fire.

However, only a gutter mesh with an aperture of 2mm or smaller that’s made from aluminium, bronze or corrosion-resistant steel (for properties in areas with a BAL of 12.5, 19 or 25) or from bronze or corrosion-resistant steel (for properties in areas with a BAL of 40 or FZ) will be designed to help your home or building withstand ember attack by keeping embers out of your gutters and the space between your gutters and roof.

When choosing between plastic and metal gutter mesh, it’s therefore important to consider whether or not you need a metal mesh to meet your bushfire resistance needs.

Corrosion 

Technically speaking, everything in nature corrodes. However, different materials corrode at different rates.

The fact that you’ve probably never heard of plastic corrosion is a good illustration of how slowly plastic tends to corrode.

However, when matched to your building’s materials and properly installed, aluminium and steel gutter mesh are also highly durable from a corrosion perspective, so regardless of your corrosion needs, both plastic and metal will generally be appropriate.

Strength 

Different types of gutter mesh have different levels of strength.

We’ve tested the strength of our range of gutter mesh with a focus on puncture resistance (to measure susceptibility to hail damage or falling branches) and load-bearing capacity (to measure susceptibility to damage from accumulated hail or snow, fallen branches and large animals). In both, aluminium proved to be strong. However, steel was consistently stronger.

Mesh strength is an important factor in any buying decision, as punctures, rips and tears can significantly compromise your gutter mesh’s performance. So you should always consider your strength requirements and select the right gutter mesh to match.

Try Mesh Matcher 

At Blue Mountain Co Gutter Mesh, we offer both Aluminium and Steel gutter mesh products.

Our comprehensive range reflects the reality that different gutter mesh options are better suited to different properties and environments.

To help you determine which metal gutter mesh option/s are fit-for-purpose for your home, we’ve designed Mesh Matcher. A quick and easy-to-use tool, Mesh Matcher helps you understand which factors you need to consider in order to select the most suitable gutter mesh for your home.

The Growing Bushfire Threat 

Australia’s bushfire seasons are becoming more intense and unpredictable. The devastating 2019–2020 Black Summer fires burned over 24 million hectares, destroyed more than 3,000 homes, and impacted communities across the country (Statista, 2023). And the risks are only increasing: 

  • Fire seasons are starting earlier and lasting longer. 
  • Extreme fire weather is becoming more frequent. 
  • The annual area burned is growing. 

Prolonged droughts, rising temperatures, and drier landscapes are creating the perfect storm for fires to ignite and spread rapidly (Bowman et al., 2017). In some regions, fire seasons are now over a month longer than they were 35 years ago (NASA, 2023). 

Your Gutters: A Hidden Fire Risk 

When it comes to bushfire preparedness, many homeowners focus on clearing vegetation around their property. But one critical weak spot is often overlooked—gutters.This phenomenon, known as an ember attack, is responsible for up to 90% of homes lost in bushfires (Leonard et al., 2016). Dry leaves and debris in gutters provide the perfect fuel, allowing fire to spread to the roof and into the home within minutes. 

Gutter Protection: A Simple Yet Powerful Defence 

 
Investing in effective gutter protection is a key step in reducing your home’s bushfire risk. At Blue Mountain Gutter Mesh, we offer premium ember guard-compliant gutter mesh, designed to defend against ember attack. Our 2mm steel and aluminium gutter mesh options meet Australian Standard AS3959-2018 for ember guard compliance while preventing flammable debris buildup in your gutters—a critical factor since up to 90% of bushfire-related property losses stem from ember ignition. Crafted from non-combustible, corrosion-resistant materials, our mesh keeps embers and leaves out, safeguarding your home. 
 
2mm Steel Gutter Mesh: Ember guard compliant for all BALs (12.5, 19, 29, 40 and Flame Zone) 

2mm Aluminium Mesh: Features a woven edge for extra durability and is ember guard compliant for BALs 12.5, 19 and 29. 

5 Signs Your Gutters Need Protection Now 

  1. Leaves and debris constantly build up. 
  2. Water spills over during heavy rain. 
  3. Your gutters are sagging or pulling away. 
  4. Stains or water damage appear on exterior walls. 
  5. You live in a bushfire-prone area. 

Bushfire Readiness Checklist: 

✅ Install ember guards to your gutters 
✅ Regularly clear gutters and roof valleys. 
✅ Remove flammable materials from around your home. 
✅ Practice your evacuation plan with your family. 

The risk of bushfires is real—and growing. Don’t wait until the flames are at your doorstep. Protect your home now, starting from the top down. 

We're here to help you build a safer, more resilient home.

Talk to our team today about ember guard solutions for your property.

 

Reference List 

  1. Statista. (2023). Impact of the 2019–2020 Australian bushfires. Retrieved from https://www.statista.com 
  1. Bowman, D. M. J. S., Balch, J. K., Artaxo, P., Bond, W. J., Cochrane, M. A., D’Antonio, C. M., … & Swetnam, T. W. (2017). Fire in the Earth System. Science, 324(5926), 481–484. doi:10.1126/science.1163886 
  1. NASA. (2023). Bushfire season length and climate trends. Retrieved from https://climate.nasa.gov 
  1. Leonard, J., Blanchi, R., Bowditch, P., & Besnard, V. (2016). Building loss due to wildfire: Trends and future risk influences. CSIRO Bushfire Research. Retrieved from https://www.csiro.au 
  1. Standards Australia. (2018). AS3959-2018: Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas. Retrieved from https://www.standards.org.au